---
title: 'No-Google Phone'
url: 'https://www.niklas-stephan.de/en/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy'
markdown: 'https://www.niklas-stephan.de/en/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy.md'
lang: en
date: '2026-04-03'
description: "No-Google Phone An overview of sustainable mobile phones in 2025 that protect the user's data. New phones are constantly thrown onto the market and tested by independent agencies, magazines and individuals. The focus of these tests, however, mostly lies on the hardware performance of the device. R…"
---

#  No-Google Phone 

---

**An overview of sustainable mobile phones in 2025 that protect the user's data.**

New phones are constantly thrown onto the market and tested by independent agencies, magazines and individuals. The focus of these tests, however, mostly lies on the hardware performance of the device. Regarding the operating system, in 99 % of cases it is simply accepted that on the device both Google and the hardware manufacturer possibly install unwanted and above all data-hungry applications. In many cases these cannot even be uninstalled.
That is why this independent test concentrates entirely on the aspect of data protection and treats the other criteria only in passing. Beforehand however we still clear up false notions about the connection between open source, Linux, Android and Google.

---

## For impatient readers: the comparison result

Here the results of the comparison at a glance. You find the exact description of the individual phones and the comparison table further below.

**Overall winner:**
**Fairphone 5** (30 points) – best combination of data protection, sustainability and everyday usability.

**Technical winner:**
**Google Pixel 8 Pro** (27 points) – outstanding camera, top hardware, long updates.

**Price-performance winner:**
**Xiaomi Poco X3 NFC** (24 points) – very good overall package at a low price, with LineageOS support.

**Ranking (points):**

1. Fairphone 5 (30)
2. Volla Phone X23 (28)
3. Google Pixel 8 Pro (27)
4. Volla Quintus (26)
5. Google Pixel 9 (26)
6. OnePlus 11 (25)
7. Motorola Edge 40 Pro (25)
8. Xiaomi Poco X3 NFC (24)
9. Motorola Moto G32 (23) 
    10. Jolla C2 Community Phone (19)

---

## Open source, Linux, Android and Google

Open source does not automatically mean data protection or security. Many people equate open-source software with secure and data-protection-friendly software, which however does not always correspond to reality. It is important to understand the differences and connections between open source, Linux, Android and the services of Google.

Open source first of all means that the source code of a software is publicly viewable. Therewith developers and experts can check the code, identify vulnerabilities and contribute to improving it.

Linux is an open-source operating system that serves as a basis for many other systems, including Android. It offers high flexibility and adaptability, however data protection and security depend strongly on the respective implementation and the services building on it. Since Android too is based on Linux, it does inherit some of the advantages of open source, but is strongly shaped by the decisions and services of Google, which can affect data protection.

That means: a mobile phone on which Android is operated without Google services can be regarded as considerably more data-protection-friendly.

## Alternatives to Android

Of course there are also other options than Android, such as Apple's iOS or other Linux-based operating systems.
iOS however is proprietary (not open source) and strongly integrated into the Apple ecosystem. On Apple mobile phones it is furthermore not possible to install alternative operating systems.
That is why Apple's phones do not represent an option in this test.

Another possibility are Linux-based operating systems such as /e/OS, LineageOS or Ubuntu Touch, which do without Google services and place the focus on data protection.
Here one again has to distinguish whether the operating system is an Android freed from the Google services, as is e.g. the case with LineageOS, or an independent distribution such as e.g. Sailfish OS.

While on the Android systems basically all applications developed for them can be run and one possibly only has to switch to an app store not operated by Google, the matter looks different with an independent distribution.

Since currently hardly any developers take part in the development of independent distributions and these also serve only a tiny target audience, there is largely yawning emptiness in the selection of applications. Nothing will change on this situation in the medium term either, which is why we will also ignore these in our test.

## Test criteria

The rating is based on the following criteria (each 0–5 points):

1. Google-free Android from the factory or installable without loss of functionality
2. Up-to-date hardware (CPU, RAM, storage)
3. Sustainability (replaceability of components)
4. Camera quality
5. Battery capacity

At maximum 30 points are reachable.

## The test candidates at a glance

### Fairphone 5

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/01-fairphone5.webp)

The Fairphone 5 is the most sustainable device in the test. It convinces with modular construction, long availability of spare parts and a replaceable battery. The hardware is solid, the camera good, and there is official support for alternative Android versions such as /e/OS and LineageOS. Whoever places value on data protection and repairability finds the best option here – even if the price lies in the upper range.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Android (LineageOS support)
Display: 6.46", 2770x1224 pixels
Rear camera: 50 MP
Front camera: 50 MP
SoC: Qualcomm QCM6490, 8 cores
RAM: 8 GB
Storage: 256 GB, microSD slot
Battery: 4200 mAh, replaceable
Specialities: IP55, MIL-STD-810H, stereo speakers
Price: €578

### Volla Phone X23

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/02-vollax23.webp)

The Volla Phone X23 comes from the factory with a Google-free Android (Volla OS) and offers a replaceable battery as well as robust construction (IP68, MIL-STD-810H). The hardware is solid, the camera good, and the price fair. For data-protection fans looking for a robust and everyday-usable device, a very good choice.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Volla OS
Display: 6.1", 1560x720 pixels
Rear camera: 48 MP + 8 MP
Front camera: 16 MP
SoC: MediaTek Helio G99, 8 cores
RAM: 6 GB
Storage: 128 GB, microSD slot
Battery: 5000 mAh, replaceable
Specialities: IP68, MIL-STD-810H
Price: €564

### Google Pixel 8 Pro

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/03-pixel8.webp)

The Pixel 8 Pro offers top hardware, an excellent camera and a long update guarantee. Thanks to LineageOS support a Google-free Android can be installed, however the way there is not quite trivial and the battery is not replaceable. Whoever places value on camera and performance and is willing to rebuild the system gets a very good overall package here.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Android 15 (update), LineageOS support
Display: 6.7", 2992x1344 pixels
Rear camera: 50 MP + 48 MP + 48 MP
Front camera: 10.5 MP
SoC: Google Tensor G3, 9 cores
RAM: 12 GB
Storage: 128 GB
Battery: 5050 mAh, built-in
Specialities: IP68, 7 years of updates
Price: €545

---

### Volla Quintus

The Volla Quintus is Volla's flagship, comes likewise with Google-free Android and very good hardware. The battery is replaceable, the display large and bright. The price however is rather high, which somewhat diminishes the price-performance ratio.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Volla OS (Android)
Display: 6.78", 2400x1080 pixels, AMOLED, 120 Hz
Rear camera: 50 MP + 8 MP + 2 MP
Front camera: 15.9 MP
SoC: MediaTek Dimensity 7050, 8 cores
RAM: 8 GB
Storage: 256 GB
Battery: 4600 mAh, replaceable
Specialities: 5G, AMOLED, wireless charging
Price: €719

---

### Google Pixel 9

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/06-pixel9.webp)

The Pixel 9 is similarly strong as the 8 Pro, somewhat more compact and cheaper. Also here there are long updates and LineageOS support. The camera is outstanding, the battery built-in. For all looking for a current, powerful device with custom-ROM option, a very good choice.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Android 15 (update), LineageOS support
Display: 6.3", 2424x1080 pixels, AMOLED
Rear camera: 50 MP + 48 MP
Front camera: 10.5 MP
SoC: Google Tensor G4, 8 cores
RAM: 12 GB
Storage: 128 GB
Battery: 4700 mAh, built-in
Specialities: IP68, 7 years of updates
Price: €569

---

### OnePlus 11

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/07-oneplus11.jpg)

The OnePlus 11 offers top hardware and is suited for custom ROMs such as LineageOS. The battery however is not replaceable and the sustainability is only average. Whoever places value on performance and a good price-performance ratio finds a strong device here.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Android (LineageOS support)
Display: 6.7", 3216x1440 pixels
Rear camera: 50 MP
Front camera: 16 MP
SoC: Snapdragon 8 Gen 2, 8 cores
RAM: 8 GB
Storage: 128 GB
Battery: 5000 mAh, built-in
Specialities: IP64, stereo speakers
Price: €538

---

### Motorola Edge 40 Pro

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/08-motorolla-edge.jpg)

The Edge 40 Pro is a powerful device with a very good camera and LineageOS support. The battery is built-in, the repairability limited. For power users who want to use a custom ROM, an interesting option.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Android (LineageOS support)
Display: 6.67", 2400x1080 pixels
Rear camera: 50 MP
Front camera: 60 MP
SoC: Snapdragon 8 Gen 2, 8 cores
RAM: 12 GB
Storage: 256 GB
Battery: 4600 mAh, built-in
Specialities: IP68, wireless charging
Price: €499

---

### Xiaomi Poco X3 NFC

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/09-poco.jpg)

The Poco X3 NFC is a cheap but capable device with LineageOS support. The installation of a Google-free system is possible, but somewhat cumbersome. The hardware is solid, the camera good, the battery large. For thrifty people with a data-protection claim, a very good choice.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Android 11 (update), LineageOS support
Display: 6.67", 2400x1080 pixels, 120 Hz
Rear camera: 64 MP + 13 MP + 2 MP + 2 MP
Front camera: 20 MP
SoC: Snapdragon 732G, 8 cores
RAM: 6 GB
Storage: 128 GB, microSD slot
Battery: 5160 mAh, built-in
Specialities: IP53, stereo speakers
Price: approx. €250

---

### Motorola Moto G32

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/10-motorola-moto-g32.png)

The Moto G32 is the cheapest device in the test and offers solid hardware for everyday use. There is LineageOS support, but the camera and performance are only average, and the battery is not replaceable. For thrifty people who place value on data protection, still a usable choice.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Android 12 (from the factory), LineageOS support
Display: 6.5", 2400x1080 pixels
Rear camera: 50 MP + 8 MP + 2 MP
Front camera: 16 MP
SoC: Snapdragon 680, 8 cores
RAM: 6 GB
Storage: 128 GB, microSD slot
Battery: 5000 mAh, built-in
Specialities: FM radio, IP52
Price: €421

---

### Jolla C2 Community Phone

![](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/user/pages/wiki/hardware/no-google-handy/11-jolla.webp)

The Jolla C2 Community Phone relies on Sailfish OS, a Linux-based system. The hardware is solid, but the battery runtime weak, no 5G, and the app selection very limited. For experiment-loving users with a focus on open source, but only conditionally recommendable in everyday use.

**Technical data:**
Operating system: Sailfish OS
Display: 6.52", 1600x720 pixels
Rear camera: 64 MP
Front camera: 16 MP
SoC: ARM Cortex, 8 cores
RAM: 8 GB
Storage: 128 GB, microSD slot
Battery: 4000 mAh, built-in
Specialities: No GPS, no 5G
Price: €284 + €60/year from the 2nd year

---

## The rating table in detail

| Criterion | Fairphone 5 | Volla X23 | Pixel 8 Pro | Volla Quintus | Pixel 9 | OnePlus 11 | Edge 40 Pro | Poco X3 NFC | Moto G32 | Jolla C2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Google-free Android (from factory/installable) | 5 | 5 | 3 | 5 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 5 |
| Hardware (CPU, RAM, storage) | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 3 |
| Sustainability (replaceability) | 5 | 4 | 2 | 3 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| Camera quality | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 |
| Battery capacity | 4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 4 | 5 | 5 | 2 |
| **Total points** | **30** | **28** | **27** | **26** | **26** | **25** | **25** | **24** | **23** | **19** |

**Legend:**
5 = fulfils the criterion completely
4 = very good, small restrictions
3 = average / acceptable
2 = below average / larger restrictions
1 = insufficient

## Conclusion

The Fairphone 5 is the best choice for all who want to combine data protection, sustainability and everyday usability. The Volla phones are very attractive for purists and data-protection fans. The Pixel devices offer the best camera and long updates, but require own initiative for a Google-free system. OnePlus and Motorola are good all-rounders if custom ROMs and price-performance stand in the foreground. The Xiaomi Poco X3 NFC is the price-performance tip for all who can live with small compromises. The Jolla C2 is an exciting experiment, but only limitedly suited for everyday use.

---

**Links:**
[Ubuntu Touch device overview](https://devices.ubuntu-touch.io)
[LineageOS](https://lineageos.org/)

---

## Navigation

- Parent: [Hardware](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/en/wiki/hardware.md)
- Previous: [Laptop](https://www.niklas-stephan.de/en/wiki/hardware/laptop.md)
